The North Fork is revered for their wineries and tasting rooms, its many B&Bs, and of course its selection of varied cuisines. Here are a few unique eateries, hand selected by two of our staff, local North Forkers themselves, who believe these hot spots have something special to offer. We hope you enjoy a taste of the North Fork!
Noah’s
Chef Noah Schwartz, who has been praised by Best Chefs America multiple times, understands the importance of keeping things local, being a native Long Islander himself. Specializing in “seafood inspired small plates”, this hot spot also caters private events, and has a food truck that travels all along the East End and in Manhattan. If you take the Jitney between the two, you can catch them on Friday evenings and early Monday mornings in Sag Harbor. This staple of Greenport village is not to be missed!
136 Front Street, Greenport
(631) 477-6720
chefnoahs.com
North Fork Roasting Co.
This brand new roastery has already created a huge buzz and has been featured in NorthForker, East of NYC, and Edible East End. Owned and run by two young hip females, these women have brought “the specialty coffee movement to the North Fork of Long Island”. This artisanal heaven for coffee drinkers is open 7 days a week.
55795 Main Road, Southold
(631) 876-5450
noforoastingco.com
Erik’s Breakfast & Lunch
A recipient of the Trip Advisor Award for Excellence, this popular spot is open year round, 7 days a week. Offering casual classics, Erik’s boasts “quality ingredients, prepared to order, and served in a friendly atmosphere at a reasonable price.” This is the perfect place to start your day off right.
43715 Middle Road, Southold
(631) 765-6264
www.eriksinsouthold.com
Deep Water Bar and Grille
This brand new eatery is owned by a North Fork local, Beth Pike who says, “If you go out, you shouldn’t have to break the bank.” Jorge Castellanos, head chef, describes the menu as “new American with a focus on seafood,” with an emphasis on “fresh”. Open 7 days a week, year round, this brand new restaurant will also offer take out as well as dockside delivery.
47 Front Street, Greenport
(631) 333-2168
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels
On Long Island bagel joints are a dime a dozen, but Goldberg’s has it right in their name, they’re famous! Besides having every type of bagel you could ever want, this popular breakfast eatery has omelets and a daily lunch menu that includes a variety of specialty sandwiches. Open 7 days a week.
10095 Main Road, Mattituck
(631) 315-5238
CJ’s American Grill
CJ’s mission statement is straightforward, “Great food, great service, great times.” This traditional American eatery has raving reviews from Restaurant.com, Yelp.com, and Tripadvisor.com, all boasting about exactly what is stated in their motto. Open 7 days a week, this hot spot not only offers weekly specials but also offers a wide variety of catering options for events.
10095 Main Road, Mattituck
(631) 315-5311
cjsamericangrill.net
Blue Canoe Oyster Bar & Grill
This popular seafood spot is open year round for lunch, a mid-day snack, and for dinner. Their ingredients are local and organic, and they “smoke their own meats and fish using hickory, bamboo, and local hardwoods”. Customers on Yelp boast about the great service, the Firecracker Shrimp, and the smokey pork butt. Their outdoor seating area offers a beautiful view of the Greenport Harbor and Shelter Island.
104 3rd Street, Greenport
(631) 477-6888
bluecanoeoysterbar.com
Soundview Restaurant
This superbly located dine-in restaurant is located directly on the Long Island Sound, offering beautiful sunset views from their seaside deck. This popular eatery started as a snack bar in 1935 called Jack’s Shack. 75 years later they serve local produce and fish, they also have a string of signature beverages. They offer live music as well as special monthly events, and they even host weddings! Open Tuesday through Sunday.
58775 Route 48, Greenport
(631) 477-0666
soundviewrestaurant.com
Orient by the Sea
Family owned and run since 1979, this famous restaurant that overlooks Gardiners Bay, offers “the perfect place to relax and have a great meal or cocktail” after a day at the beach. Their menu is filled to the brim with all the comfort foods of the North Fork, specializing in local freshly caught seafood. Open 7 days a week.
40200 Main Road, Orient
(631) 323-2424
orientbythesea.com
North Fork Tasting Room
This hidden gem is located behind the popular Lobster Roll, but offers a bit more to your inner foodie. Offering live music, wine flights, and beer tastings, this cozy spot has it all. Gourmet specialty food in addition to Lobster Roll staple dishes, this eatery has an outdoor fireplace with a conversation pit. Open Friday through Sunday.
3225 Sound Avenue, Riverhead
(631) 727-9513
northforktastingroom.com
North Fork Chocolate Company
Featured on News 12 and a winner of a Long Island Food Critic Award for Excellence, Finest Chocolatier, this is heaven for the dessert lover in everyone. Some of their products include artisanal chocolates, hand-crafted truffles, and a handful of various barks and bars. If you’re not local, don’t worry! This sweet spot delivers – in more ways than one!
740 Main Road, Aquebogue
(631) 599-4944
northforkchocolate.com
