Follow us

Best Deals On The North Fork

By Ruth Thomas

Quintessential North Fork – $549,000
The Goods – Quintessential North Fork home sits on professionally landscaped acre. Privacy is key. This property has a mini-compound feel with two-story accessory building that opens to a private pool area. Unlike anything on the market, this home is everything you want for the true North Fork experience. MLS# 2911221.

Why it’s a good deal – Listing agent Erin Kaelin of North Fork Real Estate Inc. says, “There simply is no other listing right now on the North Fork that has so many amenities for the price. A fully renovated, antique home with two-story accessory building and in-ground pool are rare enough by themselves, but add the full acre lot and professional landscaping and you have a private mini-compound feeling that isn’t matched by anything else on the market today. At $549,000 it’s priced to sell.”

Mattituck, North Fork: Retirees and First-Time Buyers Take Note – $439,000
The Goods –
This move-in ready contemporary ranch house with vaulted ceilings is located ‘within the village’ in close proximity to popular Love Lane, the movie theater, shopping, both bay and sound beaches, and public transportation. Features living room with wood-burning fireplace, dining room, eat-in-kitchen, full bath, and 3 bedrooms (including master with half bath). Large spacious basement, 2-car garage PLUS garage/shed and tent structure. Park-like 1/2 acre includes ownership of salt marsh and offers views to Mattituck Inlet. IN# 18167.

Why it’s a good deal – “You will fall in LOVE with the sunsets over Mattituck Inlet visible from your private decking and large yard/garden,” says listing agent Nicholas Planamento of Town & Country Real Estate. “An added plus of this 3-bedroom home is the oversized garage (easily converted to additional living space), living room with real wood-burning fireplace – and best of all, steps away from Strong’s Water Club, where you can keep your boat, dine, or take a plunge in their member-only pool. Ideally suited for those just starting out, seeking an affordable second home or retirees on a budget.”

Gentleman Farmer’s Property and Home – $1,295,000
The Goods – Head down the long tree-lined drive to this custom-built 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath, post modern home. Large great room with stone fireplace, gourmet open floor plan kitchen complements the offering. Acres for growing fruit, trees or flowers, perhaps horses or a vineyard. Looks out on 45 acres of preserved agricultural land. MLS# 2859930.

Why it’s a good deal – “It’s one of the best deals on the North Fork because of the amount of acreage, size of the home, reasonable taxes, expansion ability, and nearness to Long Island Sound,” says listing agent Thomas Uhlinger of Douglas Elliman Real Estate.

North Fork Dream Location! – $845,000
The Goods – Beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath cape located in the highly coveted Country Club Estates section of Cutchogue. Situated on 1 acre, this classic country home has beautiful oak wood floors, two wood-burning fireplaces and is bright and sunny throughout. The backyard is a private paradise, with mature landscaping surrounding a large in-ground pool, brick patio, and manicured lawn. Charming, yet chic, this house has it all! Close to New Suffolk Beach, Cutchogue town and award-winning restaurants and vineyards. MLS# 2903895.

Why it’s a good deal – Listing agent Kristy Naddell of Douglas Elliman Real Estate says, “It’s the only home currently available on bucolic Country Club Drive! Centrally located to surrounding towns, beaches, shopping, and dining. North Fork living at its best!”

Historic Two-Family in the Heart of Greenport – $500,000
The Goods – Location is always important and this two-family house with garage is situated in a quiet neighborhood of Historic Greenport Village. The unique features of this village farmhouse are the original exterior architectural details, high ceilings, and hardwood floors throughout. Many of the upgrades have already been completed. All that is needed now is your imagination and personal touches. This property would be a great investment as a two-family home, rental property or could easily be transformed back to a single family home. MLS# 2907840.

Why it’s a good deal – “This charming house built in 1893 has multiple options and loads of potential. With inventory down and demand high it’s difficult to find affordable opportunities within the Village of Greenport. This home has great bones and is a gem waiting to be polished,” says listing agent Jennifer Benton of Century 21 Albertson Realty.

Contemporary in the Country – $425,000
The Goods – Contemporary home with traditional charm nestled on a quiet road with deeded bay access from Jacob’s Creek. Featuring a bright open floor plan with kitchen, dining area, and living room with high ceilings, 2-3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and den/possible third bedroom. Relax on the deck and enjoy peek-a-boo water views or farm views. MLS# 2854718.

Why it’s a good deal – Listing agent Donielle Cardinale of Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty says, “This great little house is the most affordably priced ‘move-in ready’ home with this type of location on the North Fork. Close proximity to a marina, restaurant, and beach as well as deeded bay access for kayaks and paddleboards or just to sit and enjoy a glass of wine while you watch the sunset over the bay. With a recent price reduction of $25,000, it is a great value.”